Even though I work in publishing, it’s important to note I am not an editor and don’t work with agents outside of the marketing realm – I don’t handle book acquisitions and rarely have the chance to read a manuscript or chime in on the purchasing decisions. I don’t get to hear from authors before they are published or searching for the elusive contract, so I was thrilled when LeAnn Neal Reilly, author of THE MERMAID’S PENDANT, shared some of her thoughts with me on being a self-published author and her decision to take this unconventional route.
In LeAnn’s own (clever) words -
Getting an agent is essential to getting a publisher, but it was like looking for a husband who picked you from a lineup while he stood behind a two-way mirror. You didn’t really know what he wanted in a wife or whether you’d dressed appropriately. To make it worse, you weren’t sure if you’d like him or his looks. Most of the time, you waited and waited until you knew that nobody stood on the other side of the glass. Sometimes, you got a bit more information about how long to wait or a terse, written kiss-off. If you were really lucky, he might ask you to open your jacket and twirl around a bit, but even then you might not get any helpful feedback. You just didn’t get called into the next room to arrange marriage. At first, you’d try to be choosy and go to lineups for guys whose personal ad sounded like it had potential, but then you’d realize you might have to go to hundreds of lineups and end up with someone you couldn’t stand. Or someone who couldn’t perform in bed. Then you’d have to get a divorce and start over.
I decided to risk self-publishing to see if I could attract an agent or publisher that way. There have been enough stories in recent years to make me think that this path might become more common. It makes sense to me. It’s one way to let someone else pay the costs of developing a title and testing the market. I’ve done well enough at this point that even if I don’t get a bigger publisher, I’m happier than I would have been if I’d stuck my manuscript in a drawer or spent more months querying without success…
I commend Mrs. Reilly for taking the chance and getting her work out there. It’s a risk but it sounds like she did her research and made a well-informed decision. I hope
As many other tours hosts have noted, THE MERMAID’S PENDANT is a looooong book. I think the premise of “a modern fairy tale about growing up and discovering who you are” is great, but it’s lost in the length of this tome with competing subplots. I though Tamarind, the mermaid, was an interesting character but couldn’t drum up much interest in John – her lover and the main character in this novel.
Reading this book did give me fond memories of watching Disney’s The Little Mermaid in my family’s van on road trips and I thought the descriptions of the island were gorgeous and definitely made me want to plan another tropical vacation. I thank LeAnn for sharing her thoughts and wish her only the best in the future – and a huge thank you for the escapism found in the beaches of your novel!
Visit the other bloggers on this tour – the entire list is available here.


5 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 18, 2010 at 10:34 am
Lisamm
The process is so interesting and I love the way LeAnn likened it to looking for a husband (the opening the jacket part made me laugh out loud!). Thanks for the guest post and for being on the tour!
November 19, 2010 at 6:59 am
Beth F
I know that there are some gems among the self-published books, but the editor in me always distracted by the editing issues and I’m better off just not reading self-published titles.
November 19, 2010 at 7:27 am
LeAnn Neal Reilly
Lydia,
Thanks for letting me share something about my experience on your blog. You’re not alone in finding the book too long, but many of my reviewers have said the opposite, so I find myself a bit bemused. Also, just yesterday, after reading your post, I got a message from another reviewer who’d just started my novel telling me that she liked John — although she suspected she wasn’t supposed to. Another reason for me to admire and wonder at the insight publishers have when choosing books.
December 22, 2010 at 9:05 am
Jeanine Cummins
I don’t know how I haven’t run into you sooner (I worked at Penguin for ten years, and they are also my publisher), but I just found you through a twitter rec, and now your terrific blog! I love this post, and LeAnn did a stellar job self-publishing. The book looks gorgeous!
January 4, 2011 at 9:30 am
novelwhore
Jeanine I wish I had met you while you worked at Penguin; I find it such a happy place to be! It’s nice that you’re still connected through being an author now – that’s a neat way to stay in touch!