Our first brunch/book club adventure. Clever & witty name tk.
Two of my favorite past times/hobbies/activities/passions are books and brunch. Put them together and ta-da – what a fabulous day! I met the lovely ladies Nicole (@nicolebo) of Linus’s Blanket and Erica (@EricaBrooke) of Harper Perennial fame at V Bar in the East Village for mimosas, breakfast, and to talk about our first book:
Yes, we all agreed the jacket was unattractive at best. And if you can explain the tear, I’d love to hear it.
Since I just had 2.5 magnolia cupcakes, I’m on a sugar-high and can hopefully publish this post (that’s been sitting in draft since Monday) before the crash comes! This is my first real book club gathering in two years, and I must say it was charming that all three of us were racing to finish the novel right before meeting. I was ready to pack my Kindle away and walk to brunch and planned to finish the remaining 12% while sitting on a sunny bench and waiting for the ladies to arrive, when the action that had been foreshadowed the entire other 300 or so pages FINALLY happened. Needless to say I couldn’t put it down then, sped to the end before speed walking to the V.
STRANGERS AT THE FEAST was the first book I’ve read by Vanderbes (first I’d ever heard of her). I think all of us felt the same way – we expected to like it more than we did.
There is typically something universally relateable and compulsively readable about a family in crisis. Nicole pointed out that the pacing felt off – the book was quite slow, foreshadowing this massive event that was to take place and when it (don’t want to give anything away!) FINALLY happened, it wrapped up so quickly and none of us were satisfied with the conclusion.
Also, as Erica so eloquently notes in her GoodReads review: there is a bit about an adult brother and sister who “fiercely hug” every night before bed that freaked us all out. Unintentional incest overtones alert!
Our April pick (when hopefully we’ll have the whole “club” present, including Colleen @booksnyc, Jenny @jennysbooks, Miriam @MiriamParker, and Neha) is YOU KNOW WHEN THE MEN ARE GONE by Siobhan Fallon.
Addition to post: on the topic of blurbs – even though Justin Cronin’s THE PASSAGE was hugely, wildly popular, I never would have thought a quote from him of vampire fame would be relevant to this book, though it appears on the cover.



16 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 24, 2011 at 1:20 pm
scholarslip
You are so classy. I just posted about Jersey Shore.
March 24, 2011 at 1:26 pm
Jen - Devourer of Books
I’m actually not surprised that Cronin blurbed this, because I get the impression he was quite the lit fic author before he branched out to a (highly disappointing in my mind) vampire book. I have had STRANGERS AT THE FEAST on my shelves for at least 6 months, sounds like I don’t need to rush to pick it up.
March 24, 2011 at 1:43 pm
novelwhore
It wasn’t a bad book… Just not what any of us had expected. I’d think you could start about halfway through and possibly like it more, since it wouldn’t have taken so long to build up to the (disappointing) climax.
Cronin was lit fiction? Wow I never heard of him until THE PASSAGE. That’s really interesting.
March 24, 2011 at 1:57 pm
bermudaonion
Wow, what a fabulously intelligent book club! I wish I could join you!
March 24, 2011 at 3:35 pm
Rebecca Rasmussen
Dang, I love brunch and books, too — argh! This is why living in St. Louis is no good — too far to go to get to hang with all of you! Glad you had a great first meeting even if the book disappointed a little
March 24, 2011 at 8:06 pm
Barbara
I love Easter Island by Vanderbes. I was disappointed by Strangers. looks like you had a great time — brunch is my favorite meal. Siobhan’s book is good. can’t wait to hear what the Book Club Brunch Bunch think! thanks for sharing.
March 25, 2011 at 3:49 am
Nicole
I did like our version of hugging fiercely though.
March 28, 2011 at 9:19 am
novelwhore
I wish there were a “like” option for your comment!
March 25, 2011 at 3:50 pm
romance book girl
Man- your book club sounds awesome! We have a great one her in LA too, but I think I may steal the brunch idea. I am looking forward to hearing about the next one (the last one sounded a bit of a dud!)
March 28, 2011 at 9:25 am
novelwhore
@BermudaOnion, @Rebecca, @BethFish – you are all obviously welcome to join our book club as “special guests”! It would be rather like having a celebrity visitor
@Barbara – Maybe I’ll give EASTER ISLAND a try. Vanderbes is a skilled author, these characters just didn’t do it for us.
@Romance Book Girl – brunch is so much fun. If you try it with your club you’ll have to let me know how it goes! I’m looking forward to the discuss of Siobhan’s book – yes, this pick wasn’t the most thrilling.
@Jenny – Already looking forward to April!
March 26, 2011 at 4:50 am
Beth F
I wonder if I could manage to come to NYC just for brunch and then turn right around and come home. Sounds like the best book club ever. (Although my Skype club is pretty darn great.)
March 26, 2011 at 12:28 pm
Jenny
So sad I missed it! I had the same reaction to the book, particularly the issue of the pacing. I mean it built up and built up, to the point that I found the foreshadowing heavy-handed, and yeah, the actual events went by in a flash. Particularly the denouement.
March 31, 2011 at 5:31 pm
Review: Strangers at the Feast, Jennifer Vanderbes « Jenny's Books
[...] this. I just had problems with certain aspects of it. I read it as the first pick for the new New York bloggers’ book club, and I think it was an excellent pick for a book club. Lots of issues to discuss (maybe too many?). [...]
April 2, 2011 at 1:29 pm
S. Krishna
I really need to move to NYC so I can join your book club.
April 26, 2011 at 8:39 pm
The Girl from the Ghetto
I absolutely love Erica, and it thrills me to know that you are friends with her!
Like S. Krishna, I want to move to NYC to join your book club, too.
May 16, 2011 at 12:32 pm
Farin
I loved ‘You Know When the Men Are Gone.’ Curious to hear what you ladies think!